Advancements in materials used in bicycle frames school of. Which frame material is best competitive gear erie pa. You have clicked a page that seems to be very popular. The most traditional frame material, steel has been used by framebuilders for over a century. There are many more bicycle frame builders in america than in the uk, and my.
However, when compared to these other materials, aluminum is more. From the finite element analysis composite is a structural material that consists of. Because of its decreased density, it requires larger tube diameters to achieve enough strength for a bike frame. This is why a constraint of density is to be limited at 5000 kgm3. The earliest bikes were simple wooden framed push along affairs but soon the material of choice was heavy iron, which in turn was superseded by steel. Nondestructive evaluation of carbon fiber bicycle frames. Jul 27, 2016 according to cycling historians, the first bike was constructed in 1817 completely of wood. Its a mountain bike frame with shocks, so i decided to replace the entire frame with a city bike aluminum frame i only use the bike if i have to pick upbuy some stuff near home. Since the backbone of any bike is its frame, it can be enlightening to understand how its made and what that means for you, the cyclist. Remove some air pressure from your tires so that the tires are not at maximum pressure during shipping.
The fender maker designs their products around a certain range of frame sizes. Pdf choosing the optimum material for making a bicycle frame. Pdf materials for bicycle frame system a case study on the. Although wires are strong, they cannot directly replace wooden spokes that carry loads in compression. Steel steel is real as the old saying goes, or is it a new saying coined when alternative frame materials became more and more popular. Section 3 talks about different frame materials that gt uses. Bicycles stack exchange is a question and answer site for people who build and repair bicycles, people who train cycling, or commute on bicycles. Bicycle frame materials explained bikeexchange blog. Steel was the universal choice of racing bike frames until aluminium appeared in the 1970s and 1980s and carbon fiber took over in the 1990s.
How do i know if the frame that i replaced is a titaniumsteel. The mechanical pro perties of common bike frame materials are. Steel is the best balance of cost weight and durability. Your frame manufacturer develops the rear triangle with a certain tire size and clearance in mind. Jan 11, 2017 several years ago, i tboned a car at about 20 mph when it turned right into my path while i was riding my bike pictured above. May 17, 2009 bcycle frames there are different kind of bcycle frame. We will involve physical aspects of materials structure, properties, etc.
Frames are required to be strong, stiff and light, which they do by. The aim is always to make the strongest, lightest frame possible for the money. If you were to call me and ask me what material i recommend this is what id say. Elementary aspects of road bicycle design, engineering and. Steel was the material of choice for a long time in the bike industry until aluminium came along in the 1970 and 80s. The diagram shows the frame geometry of a conventional bicycle.
This is a simplified description of material as applied in a custom bicycle frame. Thanks to a high stiffness to weight ratio, ability to customize frame shapes, high resistance to fatigue and the experimentation it affords manufacturers to create whatever product they desire, its no surprise that we are currently living in the age of carbon. Jamuna assistant professor, mechanical department, aim. Choosing the optimum material for making a bicycle frame 6. International journal of engineering trends and technology. This encompasses common frame materials such as aluminium and titanium alloys. As others have pointed out, you need to give us a price point, as thatll make a huge difference as to what materials are even realistically available to you. This paper has outlined a fe model using beam elements to represent a standard road bicycle frame.
New materials have advantages over carbon fiber for bike frames. A given cubic volume of aluminum weighs as much as the same volume of steel. One answer per material please, with an example of a bicycle frame using that material. However, nowadays the ride of an aluminium frame can be exceptional. Materials for bicycle frame system a case study on the development of selection method conference paper pdf available february 2010 with 9,602 reads how we measure reads. However, there are also frames made of wood, bamboo, thermoplastic, and magnesium. Pdf materials selection of a bicycle frame using cost. This paper talks about selection of material for bicycle frame and their comparison. If the bike frame were to flex, it could throw the balance of the rider off because the bike would feel spongy beneath them. It is less dense than steel, so it results in lighter frames. Carbon or hightensile steel is a good, strong, longlasting steel, but it isnt as light as its more hightech brother, the steel known as chromoly.
To supply the answers, we went to some of the most famous frame builders in the world. Steel is the most commonly used material in bike frames. The trek 2000 is clearly the stiffest frame of the three, since it is lowest in strain energy absorption. Internal butting looking at the tube, you wont notice butting because its hidden within the tube. It contains few alloys, which are additional metals that improve its strengthtoweight ratio, and is the weakest of all the types of steel used in bike frames.
Pdf materials for bicycle frame system a case study on. If you want a more technical and detailed description of materials. And you need the material where the bike frame undergoes the most stressat each. This senior project is an educational case study on the material science of bicycle wheels, frame, components and helmets. Introduced as a material for bicycle frames about 30 years ago, aluminum is now the most common material. A lightweight material is vital to create the ideal bicycle frame to improve manoeuvrability, braking and acceleration performance. Soon after came steel, then aluminum alloy, spaceage. Soon after came steel, then aluminum alloy, spaceage carbon fiber, and now titanium. The fatigue testing was done inhouse using a test rig specifically built for this project according to the astm standard f271108 for horizontal loading. The excessive use of more material to reinforce frames resulted in stiff frames before designs became more refined. When carbon became the material of choice in fabricating frames in the late 1990s, new challenges arose.
Reynolds took out his patent on butted steel bicycle tubes and, for steel aficionados, a frame bearing the reynolds stamp is a must have to the present day. I have left many details out in an effort to keep the conversation focused and simple. The semimetallic element boron is currently all the rage in carbon fiber frames. Pdf materials selection of a bicycle frame using cost per. Now the obvious conclusion that one can draw from this is that a frame of aluminum should end up weighing the same as a steel frame. Bicycle frame building in the usa winston churchill memorial trust. Alibaba manufacturer directory suppliers, manufacturers.
A strong and durable touring frame can be constructed out of aluminium, steel or titanium. Stiffness affects the riding qualities of a bike frame, since a frame suffers no per manent deformation in normal riding. When choosing frame material, take the time to evaluate your priorities. It is sturdy and can withstand quite a bit of abuse. This is about weight, and the related topic of frame material. Praised for its sustainability, bamboo wins the prize for the most sustainable frame material. Because carbon is an anisotropic material, the engineering skill required suddenly moved out of reach for many fabricators. The material is much heavier than carbon or aluminum, which is one of the reasons steel isnt used in todays pro peloton. An existing frame of hero cycle as a reference for design. Through their manipulation of steel, aluminum and titanium, the builders of bespoke. Touring bikes have a long wheelbase due to a combination of a slack head angle, long fork rake and long chainstay length. The publication presents the designs of six internationally renowned bicycle builders whose embrace of the tradition of working in metal brings striking innovation to their craft. Bike manufacturers use a wide range of materials to make their frames, many of them very sophisticated.
The slight weight disadvantage that comes with a steel frame makes it unusable for racing at the highest levels. Steel frames at one time was the only frame material. Touring bikes 10501070mm road bikes 996mm cx 1018mm. Specify frame tubing in terms of diameter and wall thickness to achieve durability and use requirements according to established industry practices. Design a frame to customer measurements and requirements, using a computeraided design cad program or other means. Its worth noting that its often how the chosen material is used by the engineers and manufacturers that matters most, and this is something that each brand will typically play with. Touring bike 445470mm road bikes 405415mm cx 420435mm. The handbuilt bicycle julie lasky michael maharam sacha white. A bicycle frame is the main component of a bicycle, onto which wheels and other components are fitted. Seat tube length isnt too important for most people with the exception of those who need additional standover.
A solid model of the frame was created and a finite element analysis fea was conducted using the astm standard as a. Frame weight versus strain energy for startup load case. As soon as you want to swap out tires or reuse your older fenders, youll be stuck with some illfitting polycarbonate. Dyuti 2 1 department of manufacturing and materials engineering, international. Cfrp is the most popular material for highperformance cycling due to the stiffnesstoweight ratio. That said, just because the ett is the same between the two bikes, it doesnt mean the bikes will have the same reach. We can use for a frame carbon fiber,aleminium alloys or pure steel. Structural analysis of bicycle frame using composite laminate arun sam varghese 1, sreejith n.
Keywords carbonepoxy composite, laminate code, quasiisotropic laminate, maximum stress theory, design parameter r. In the bicycle wheel, wires replace the rigid spokes of wooden wheels. A longer wheelbase provides a more stable and comfortable ride. The 4 most common bicycle frame materials infolific. The effective top tube ett length is the simplest way to determine a bikes size. Please use the format ive used in my answers to make it easy to compare materials.
Nonetheless, aluminium is a more brittle and weaker material than steel, and as such frames tend to be slightly overbuilt to make frames stronger and give a. Bcycle frames there are different kind of bcycle frame. Mar 23, 2015 specialized does have a takeback program in place, but recycling involves chopping the fibers into smaller pieces, so that reclaimed material wont find another life as a new bike frame. My titanium bike frame escaped unscathed while the front fork. Steel is durable, totally resistant to fatigue stress when used for standard bike riding anyway and easily repaired. As soon as you want to swap out tires or reuse your older fenders, youll. Pdf this paper presents the results obtained following the finite element method fem simulations on a bike frame made of 3 different. Materials for bicycle frame system a case study on the development of selection method m. This material has not done well in the bicycle frame industry due to its reactivity, corrosivity, and difficulty to weld. Reports stated that the ride was very harsh, but the frame was also very laterally exible. Carbon fiber is undoubtedly the wonder material for modern day bikes regardless of the discipline.
Bicycle materials case study university of washington. A look at how to approach a frame build and why youd want to tackle a build in the first place. The best aluminum frames have fat, thinwall tubes and dont deflect much side to side when you sprint. Material and design optimization for an aluminum bike frame. Parametric finite element analysis of bicycle frame geometries. Material selection for a bicycle linkedin slideshare. In order to work, wires must be tensioned to prevent their buckling under load. But because it has the strength, one would need 3 times the material to make a given structure work. The model simulates two standard loading conditions to understand the vertical compliance and lateral stiffness characteristics of 82 existing bicycle frames from the bicycle geometry project and compares these characteristics to an optimised solution in these conditions. And you need the material where the bike frame undergoes the most stressat each end of the various tubes. This type of stress induced on a frame is considered an inplane bending moment see figure 1. The materials used for bike frames have a wide range of mechanical properties. The modern and most common frame design for an upright bicycle is based on the safety bicycle, and consists of two triangles.
Jun 27, 2018 the most common bicycle frame material, aluminum is known for being corrosion resistant, fairly light though typically not as light as carbon fiber, and having a high strengthtoweight ratio. According to cycling historians, the first bike was constructed in 1817 completely of wood. Aluminum has a titanium and carbon fiber favorable strength to weight ratio, and a lower cost compared to other materials used for bicycles. The bicycle frame the bicycle frame is the main load bearing structure of the bicycle and in order to select materials for its construction or to make an efficient frame design the loads carried by the various components must be evaluated under realistic conditions. With tension, wires can support compression loads up to the point where they become slack. It is lighter than almost anything else used for bike frames, very strong, does not rust, does not fatigue, and produces very responsive bike. Weight, strength, safety, and frame materials its been said that most people care about three things.
Several years ago, i tboned a car at about 20 mph when it turned right into my path while i was riding my bike pictured above. Understanding how each material may serve your priorities will tell you which material is best for you. There are two distinct types of steel used in the bicycle industry. Specialized does have a takeback program in place, but recycling involves chopping the fibers into smaller pieces, so that reclaimed material wont find. The most common bicycle frame material, aluminum is known for being corrosion resistant, fairly light though typically not as light as carbon fiber. The aim of the work is design, analysis and fabricate. The most common bicycle frame material, aluminum is known for being corrosion resistant, fairly light though typically not as light as carbon fiber, and having a high strengthtoweight ratio. Each bicycle frame material offers a list of differing characteristics that will affect the cost, comfort, weight, stiffness, strength and durability. Materials selection of a bicycle frame using cost per unit property and digital logic methods article pdf available in international journal of mechanical and materials engineering 51. Fibers or whiskers of material can be oriented within the composite to stabilize dynamic forces to different degrees and directions on different parts of the bicycle frame. Plus, there are myriad methods of assembly making steel very adaptable to cyclists needs.
New materials have advantages over carbon fiber for bike. A steel frame can be made that weighs in the mid to low 3pound range. The idea of this bicycle material selection case study is to increase the knowledge of the reader of the case study, as well as the author. Materials, and manufacturing processes which convert the material into a useful part, underpin all of engineering design. Frame material is just one factor of the overall frame design. Design bicycle frame and specify materials and components. Hightensile steel, or hiten as it is often abbreviated, is the most inexpensive type of steel used in bike frames. The bador is the most flexible frame, since it is highest in strain energy storage. It is lighter than almost anything else used for bike frames, very strong, does not rust, does. This article uses fem results to compare three different materials for bike frames. What better way to learn about the littleknown art of frame building than to personally visit the masters. Frame materials for the tourist adventure cycling association.
32 739 254 1114 871 1094 1316 1458 692 389 1004 395 112 132 159 668 756 966 520 1029 207 576 949 1337 782 832 212 146 692 710 883 1455 86 547 210 1303